Overscheduled Summers Are Stealing Something From Our Kids

My Little Wallaby
Two children running barefoot on a grass lawn in bright Australian summer light, a garden hose lying nearby, no organised activity in sight.

In short

  • Australian summer holidays run six weeks — and the pressure to fill them with camps, lessons, and programs has intensified sharply in recent decades.
  • Sociologist Annette Lareau's research on "concerted cultivation" helps explain the anxiety: structured activity has come to feel like good parenting, and unstructured time like its absence.
  • The research on organised activities, including Mahoney and Cairns (2007), consistently shows diminishing returns beyond moderate participation. The unscheduled week is not a parenting failure.

The emails start arriving long before the holidays do. Not yet summer, not even close, but already: have you registered? Early bird closes Friday. Spots are filling fast. By the time schools break up in mid-December, most parents of young children have already sorted the first three weeks. Swimming intensive at the leisure centre. Drama camp at the community hall. The week at the grandparents', pencilled in. The fourth week, someone will work something out.

Six weeks is a long time. That's the reasoning behind the filling. Six weeks is also, in Australian family history, simply what summer was — a long open stretch of heat and days and the loose, unhurried time that children once occupied themselves. The backyard with a hose. The beach on Tuesdays. The cousins over for four days running, sleeping on the lounge floor. An almost total absence of structure that nobody thought to call anything, because nobody thought it needed naming.

The idea that this kind of time had value, that it was giving children something that an activity could not, was too ordinary to remark on. We are only beginning to remark on it now that it is disappearing.

The logic behind the filling

In 2003, the American sociologist Annette Lareau published Unequal Childhoods, a study in which she observed twelve American families across class lines, watching how they organised their children's lives. The middle-class families, she found, practiced what she called "concerted cultivation": a parenting ideology in which the child's development is understood as a project, and structured activities — sport, music, tutoring, enrichment — as the tools of that project. These parents organised their children's lives around organised programs. They reasoned, not irrationally, that participation was investment, and that investment was love.

The working-class families she observed practiced something different, which Lareau called "accomplishment of natural growth." Children in these families had more unstructured time. They played with neighbourhood kids, occupied themselves, moved within the rhythms of family life rather than around a schedule of external commitments. The parents believed that providing safety and love was sufficient, and that children's development would unfold accordingly.

Lareau was not arguing that one approach was correct and the other mistaken. She was describing. But her description has become increasingly useful as a lens on Australian family life in the twenty years since, because concerted cultivation is now, broadly, the water most middle-class Australian parents swim in — including during summer.

The anxiety isn't irrational. In a world where credentials accumulate early and competitive pressure is real, doing something feels like doing something. Sitting in a backyard under a sprinkler feels, to the adult who has absorbed the concerted-cultivation framework, like doing nothing — even when the child is perfectly content, learning to occupy themselves, having exactly the kind of free, self-directed time developmental psychologists would recognise as valuable.

What the research says about organised activities

Joseph Mahoney and Robert Cairns, researchers at the University of California Irvine and University of North Carolina respectively, spent years studying the effects of organised out-of-school activities on child development. Their 2007 findings, widely cited in the developmental literature, showed that moderate participation in organised activities was associated with positive outcomes — social skills, academic engagement, identity formation. But beyond moderate participation, the picture changed. Diminishing returns set in. And the costs mounted: less time for free play, less family time at the family's own pace, less opportunity for the kind of boredom that, as Teresa Belton's research has shown, pushes children into self-directed invention.

The development researcher Peter Benson, who created the Search Institute's Developmental Assets framework, identified forty factors associated with healthy development in young people. Unstructured time, creative activity, and family togetherness all appear on the list. A packed schedule that serves children's enrichment while eliminating all three simultaneously is a trade-off, not an optimisation.

Peter Gray, a developmental psychologist at Boston College, published a landmark analysis in 2011 in American Journal of Play tracing the decline of children's free play from the 1950s to the 2000s. The decline, he found, was steep and consistent — and correlated with rising rates of anxiety, depression, and a reduced sense of internal locus of control in young people. Gray's argument isn't romantic. He is not asking for a return to some imagined golden era. He is pointing at a measurable cost in children's wellbeing that tracks, closely, with the organised filling of time that was once left open.

What summer used to do

The Australian summer break has its own particular character. Six weeks of mid-January heat, long light until eight in the evening, and a national mood of slight suspension — offices quiet, roads emptier, the tempo of adult life slowing in ways that family life can follow. Christmas then New Year then those wide, hazy weeks of January that have no name and no particular agenda. Extended family close, or closer than usual. The particular laziness of a hot afternoon when doing anything active is beside the point.

That quality of suspended time — time that has not been divided into slots and assigned to purposes — gave children something specific. It gave them the experience of time as theirs. Not their teacher's time, not their coach's time, not the camp coordinator's time. Their time, to fill or not fill as they could manage.

A child who spends a fortnight of summer moving between the backyard, the beach, the cousins, and the slow boredom of a hot afternoon — who builds something badly, abandons it, finds something else, cycles through restlessness and invention and restlessness again (the very thing independent play is built from) — is learning something that a swim squad or a drama camp, however good, cannot teach. They are learning that they can occupy themselves. They are learning the texture of their own preferences.

This isn't an argument against holiday camps or organised programs. It's an argument against the logic that treats an unscheduled week as a gap to be filled rather than a resource to be used.

What over-scheduling costs the family

There's a second cost to the packed summer schedule that rarely appears in the developmental literature, because it's harder to measure: what it costs the adults. The logistics of six weeks of back-to-back activities — the registrations, the drop-off times, the packed lunches, the coordination across multiple programs, the family holiday that now needs to be carved out from a schedule already organised around children's camps rather than the family's own pace — are considerable.

Lareau noted this in her observations. The middle-class families in her study were frequently exhausted by the schedule they had constructed. Their family life was organised around their children's activities rather than around family rhythms. The unstructured time she observed in working-class families — the afternoons of the children playing in the street while adults sat on the porch — was, in some ways, easier on the adults as well as the children.

The summer break is one of the few stretches of the year where a different pace is genuinely available. Most Australian families are not on the school run, not in the routine, not maintaining the term's architecture. Six weeks is long enough to live differently for a while. The question is whether we are willing to let the calendar reflect that, or whether we fill it from habit and anxiety until the holidays are over before we have had them.

The case for doing less, deliberately

The argument here is not "do nothing." It is "do less, on purpose, and trust what the nothing gives them." None of this is as easy in practice as it is to describe — when the bored complaint starts up on day four, the holiday program website is right there.

One week of a good holiday program followed by a week of very little. A beach trip with no planned activities. A January afternoon with the hose running and no plan for what happens next. These are not failures of imagination or ambition. They are an environment in which children encounter their own resourcefulness, and — as Sandi Mann, Lyn Fry, and Teresa Belton all converge on suggesting — come out the other side of the discomfort having built something that a structured program could not build for them.

The Australian summer, if you let it, is still very good at this. The heat slows everything down. The long evenings invite the backyard. The extended family who are suddenly available for a few days bring a different kind of stimulation from anything you could book online. The kids who are bored by Wednesday afternoon and wandering the house making noise about it are, if you can hold your nerve, on the threshold of something.

You don't have to fill it. That's harder to hold onto in practice than it is to read — especially in a year when everyone around you seems to have their children enrolled in something. But the summer is pretty good at filling itself, if you give it the chance.

Frequently asked questions

How many activities is too many for a child?

Joseph Mahoney and Robert Cairns, in their 2007 research on organised activities, found that moderate participation — one or two activities at a time — is associated with positive developmental outcomes. Beyond that, the benefits plateau and then reverse. The costs include reduced free time, less self-directed play, and a family schedule that becomes organised entirely around children's activities rather than the family's own pace. The marker to watch is not a specific number but whether there is any unstructured time left in the week.

Is it bad to send kids to holiday camps?

Not at all. Holiday camps can be wonderful. The problem is not any single camp — it is the logic of filling the entire break from the first day to the last, so that the holiday becomes structurally identical to the school term. A week of something followed by a week of genuinely unscheduled time is very different from six weeks of back-to-back activities.

Why do Australian parents over-schedule their kids?

Sociologist Annette Lareau, in Unequal Childhoods (2003), identified "concerted cultivation" as a middle-class parenting ideology in which structured activities are understood as investments in the child's future. The anxiety driving over-scheduling is not irrational — in a competitive world, doing things feels like doing something. The cost is that what children need from downtime is invisible in a way that organised activity is not.

What do children actually need from school holidays?

According to Peter Gray's 2011 analysis of free-play decline in American Journal of Play, children need time that belongs to them — not structured by adults, not evaluated, not aimed at any outcome. The Australian summer break, with its particular character of heat and long light and the slowed pace of family life, has historically provided exactly that. The question is whether we are still letting it.

What is concerted cultivation?

Concerted cultivation is the term Annette Lareau used in Unequal Childhoods to describe the parenting approach common in middle-class families, in which childhood is treated as a project to be managed and optimised through organised activities, structured enrichment, and adult-directed learning. Lareau contrasted this with "accomplishment of natural growth," observed in working-class families, where children were given more unstructured time and expected to develop within family rhythms rather than organised programs.

Related reading

Sources

Back to blog
1 of 3